• WorkTime
  • Evaluate
  • Buy
  • Prices
  • Compare
  • WorkTime
  • Evaluate
  • Buy
  • Prices
  • Compare
17 Feb In Legal Aspects Legal Aspects - Per Country Questions - Answers

USA Employee Monitoring Laws: Are Employers Allowed to Monitor Employee Personal Emails & Messages?


employee monitoring legal

Q: Are employers allowed to monitor employee personal emails & messages?
A: Employers have the right to monitor a company’s equipment, including monitoring messages and emails sent using this equipment.

US employers have the right to monitor their property. In other words, in the USA employers have the right to monitor computers, servers, and other electronic devices that belong to a company and are provided by the employer to employees to perform work-related activities. So, any email or message, sent using an employer’s property, might be monitored, regardless whether is it work-related or personal.

In general, the monitoring practice is widely applied and allowed in the US. As cited by Law360 ( New York, 2009), a 2007 survey conducted by the American Management Association suggests that 66 percent of companies monitor employees’ Internet connections, 45 percent of employers track employees’ keystrokes and time spent at the keyboard and 43 percent of companies monitor employees’ e-mail.

However, every state has its local regulations as to the issue of employee monitoring legacy. For example, certain states require that employers provide notice to their employees before doing so, and several states have pending legislation that would require prior notice.

Specifically, Connecticut and Delaware currently have laws requiring employers to provide notice before conducting electronic monitoring, and New York, Massachusetts, and Pennsylvania all have legislation pending that would require notice before conducting electronic monitoring. ( Connecticut General Statute § 31-48d; The Delaware Statute  § 705; The Massachusetts Bill § 3(a)-(b); The Pennsylvania’s Statute  § 2(b); A. 3871, 2009-2010, Reg. Sess. N.Y. 2009)

The law provides exceptions: where an employer suspects an employee of engaging in misconduct. If an employer has “reasonable grounds” to believe that employees are engaged in conduct which (1) violates the law; (2) violates the legal rights of the employer or other employees, or; (3) creates a hostile workplace environment; and electronic monitoring “may produce evidence of this misconduct,” the employer may conduct monitoring without giving prior written notice. Id. at § 31-48d(b).

The workplace privacy regulations (or the core principles of legal employee monitoring) include using employers’ equipment for monitoring, communicating monitoring intentions to employees, and applying software for business purposes by employees. According to the Precedent Law, all these are deemed to be relevant to the limited expectation of privacy by employees. E.g. If an email system is used as a corporate’s one, the employer is allowed to review its contents, including personal mail.

Privacy Rights Clearinghouse, a non-profit corporation located in California, states that: “Messages sent within the company as well as those that are sent from the company’s terminal to another company or from another company to an employee’s device can be subject to monitoring by the employer. This may include web-based email accounts such as Gmail and Yahoo as well as instant messages.”

Q: How are employees protected?
A: There are laws protecting employees privacy.

Various state and federal laws prohibit unauthorized access to electronic communications and invasion of privacy. Unauthorized access means non-communicated monitoring practice, and privacy invasion implies unreasonable surveillance of employees.  Again, the law varies depending on the state.

The Stored Communications Act (SCA) provides that “whoever intentionally accesses without authorization a facility through which an electronic communication service is provided . . . and thereby obtains, alters or prevents authorized access to a wire or electronic communication while it is in electronic storage . . . shall be punished as provided. . . ”, 18 U.S.C. § 2701(a).  However, the SCA permits access to a stored communication when consent is provided by the user. 18 U.S.C. § 2701(c)

In addition, a few states have enacted statutes specifically requiring employers to give notice when monitoring employees’ activities on electronic devices. Examples have been provided in the previous answer.

Q: How are employers protected?
A: There is legislation protecting employers.

According to the federal Electronic Communications Privacy Act (ECPA), an employer-provided computer system is the property of the employer. That is why, when monitoring employees, employers are protected by the law when corporate equipment and business-oriented software is used.

Moreover, when an employer suspects an employee of being engaged in misconduct and corporate policy breach, nor prior notice for the monitoring is required, as explained by Weil business law company. For example, employers in New York would be able to conduct electronic monitoring without giving prior written notice where they have reasonable grounds to believe that employees are engaged in misconduct and electronic monitoring may produce evidence of this misconduct.

As shown by the Precedent Law, it is difficult for an employee to argue successfully that he or she has had a reasonable expectation of privacy in e-mails at work if a corporate policy includes the monitoring practice. As with some of the statutes mentioned in the first answer, the notice would have to be in writing or in electronic format and acknowledged by the employee in a similar manner.

Q: What do professional lawyers suggest?
A: They suggest being reasonable when implementing the monitoring tool at the workplace.

Professional lawyers suggest, there are the core principles to follow when applying employee monitoring at the workplace.

1. Using employers’ equipment (computers or cell-phones)

The Precedent Law states that when employees apply an employer’s equipment, including any gadgets available, – their expectation of privacy should be limited.

2. Communicating and negotiating monitoring intentions

Negotiated monitoring is deemed to be legal. Employee computer monitoring intentions are usually communicated via corporate Policies in various ways: through employee handbooks, via memos or meetings, or union contracts.

3. Applying monitoring software for business purposes

Employee monitoring software must serve reasonable business goals. If no spyware functions are predetermined, then the software is considered to be a productivity or performance monitoring one.

Disclaimer

This article provides general information only. This information is for general understanding only and not to be used as legal advice. To receive professional legal advice, please consult your lawyer.

By WorkTime employee monitoring software www.worktime.com







  • OUR PRODUCTS

    WorkTime Corporate
    On-premises employee productivity monitoring software for companies from 1 to 15,000+ employees/computers. FREE for small businesses.

    Evaluate FREE Now


    WorkTime Cloud
    Web-based employee monitoring service to monitor employees remotely and in-office. FREE for small teams.

    Sign Up Now FREE!


  • Categories

    • Employee Computer Monitoring Blog (267)
      • Articles (101)
      • Case Studies (11)
      • Computer & Health (2)
      • E-Books (2)
      • For Self-Employed (1)
      • Infographics (12)
      • Knowledge Base (4)
      • Legal Aspects (24)
        • Legal Aspects – How To (4)
        • Legal Aspects – Per Country (9)
      • News (46)
      • Press Releases (37)
      • Questions – Answers (69)
        • Questions – Answers – How To (38)
        • Questions – Answers – Myth/Real (11)
        • Questions – Answers – What Is (16)
      • Video (12)
      • White Papers (5)
    • Productivity Tips (31)
  • Search

  • Recent Posts

    • How does computer monitoring software work? How to choose safe software?
      07 Feb
    • How To Manage Remote Distributed Team
      23 Jan
    • Employee Monitoring Software WorkTime – Boxing Week Sale – NesterSoft Inc
      27 Dec
    • Boxing Week Discounts
      19 Dec
    • WorkTime Employee Monitoring Software 10.5 Released
      19 Dec




  • WorkTime
    Compare Editions
    Prices
    Evaluate
    Buy
  • Products
    WorkTime Corporate
    WorkTime Cloud

    WorkTime Professional
    WorkTime Corporate Free
    WorkTime Cloud Free
    WorkTime Personal Free
    SpyDetect Free
  • Info Centre
    News
    Legal Aspects
    Case Studies
    Press Releases
    White Papers
    E-Books
    More...
  • Company
    About
    Resellers
    Careers

    Got Questions? Need Assistance?
    1-877-717-8463
    info@worktime.com

    NesterSoft Inc.
    3737 Major Mackenzie Dr. #42477
    Woodbridge, ON, L4H 3M2
    Canada

         

Copyright © NesterSoft Inc. 1998-2019. All rights reserved. WorkTime is a registered trademark of NesterSoft Inc.
All other product names and trademarks are the property of their respective holders.